Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
"The Bloods" Cricket Chat Forum -> DDCA News -> Turf 2 top 4
Post Info TOPIC: Turf 2 top 4
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
RE: Turf 2 top 4
Permalink Closed

correct FT, for example MM's would have turf 2 and turf 4, if MM'S win flag they both go up.

__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
G Train


Status: Offline
Posts: 4528
Date:
Permalink Closed

couldn't disagree more sir.

__________________

LRQ - Laughing Really Quietly. Get on it!
Tangles


Status: Offline
Posts: 292
Date:
Permalink Closed

sir wrote:

correct FT, for example MM's would have turf 2 and turf 4, if MM'S win flag they both go up.


But what if there T4 were getting smashed every week this would make it a joke.

 



__________________

Chappy what a legend!!!!!!
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

Tangles wrote:

There would be some mother of all hidings i reckon Sir. Some clubs just plain have no depth. No offence to Springvale but could you imagine them in t1.


springvale for example would play turf 2 and their 2nds turf 4, now if they havent the depth then they shouldnt be in the comp.

 



__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
G Train


Status: Offline
Posts: 4528
Date:
Permalink Closed

It would be a farce sir, you're kidding yourself man.

__________________

LRQ - Laughing Really Quietly. Get on it!
Tangles


Status: Offline
Posts: 292
Date:
Permalink Closed

sir wrote:

Tangles wrote:

There would be some mother of all hidings i reckon Sir. Some clubs just plain have no depth. No offence to Springvale but could you imagine them in t1.


springvale for example would play turf 2 and their 2nds turf 4, now if they havent the depth then they shouldnt be in the comp.

 


It does make it hard though becasue some sides will never be able to attract players like other clubs. So we may have a revolving door of lots of teams up and down.

 



__________________

Chappy what a legend!!!!!!
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

its all about having say 20 strong clubs, so if 4 or 5 clubs such as springy, silverton, doveton nth havent got the depth and cant have 2 decent turf sides then they move on or play A grade.

__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

G Train wrote:

It would be a farce sir, you're kidding yourself man.


no im not jarrod. why? its fucccking easy.

 



__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
Tangles


Status: Offline
Posts: 292
Date:
Permalink Closed

But Sir some clubs do use there lower turf grades as feeders for kids and are happy to have 2-4 wins a year. Kids get some great experience on turf as well. I just couldnt see how it would work. How many teams would there be in each grade?

__________________

Chappy what a legend!!!!!!
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

maybe 10 or 11 in each grade.

__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
G Train


Status: Offline
Posts: 4528
Date:
Permalink Closed

The only way i could see it working is if they adopt a similar concept to the West Gippy and go to 8 team competitions. Even if it means there is 7 or 8 Turf grades. It's by far and away the fairest and best way of structuring a competition i've ever seen. Only problem is, the bottom half teams in Turf 1 and Turf 2 would never allow it to go ahead, for risk of dropping out of one of the top divisions. If you don't do something like that then Sir's proposed competition would be far too lopsided.

__________________

LRQ - Laughing Really Quietly. Get on it!
prince mark


Status: Offline
Posts: 3187
Date:
Permalink Closed

I don't like it Sir, would be too many terribly one sided games, day 1 outrights even. I think what we have now is fine

__________________

G Train


Status: Offline
Posts: 4528
Date:
Permalink Closed

Spot on prince. It's all good but could be even better if they went the WGCA way.

__________________

LRQ - Laughing Really Quietly. Get on it!
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

why would it be lopsided?

__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

grades may look like this, fixture would also mean 1st and 2nds play against same club. 

turf 1 & 3
sscc
buckley
berw
park
dov
nth dandy
dand w
hallam
st marys
mordi
narre

turf 2 & 4
keys
coom
lyn
hsd
cran
h/park
narre nth
f/gate
mm's
sth pir
st brid 

teams not inculded, dov nth, silverton, springvale, lynbrook.  


__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
prince mark


Status: Offline
Posts: 3187
Date:
Permalink Closed

Turf 3 would be a joke in that scenario Sir, tue turf 1 clubs that have turf 4 are in that grade for a reaso and the turf 2 clubs that have turf 3 are in that grade Coz they were too good for t4

__________________

sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

they would work it out prince the weaker teams, they would have to. currently in turf 2 there is only two 2nds teams, couple of years ago there was at least 4, berwick and nth dandy come to mind who now play turf 3.  


__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

with the set up ive mentioned only two clubs named in turf 1 have their 2nds in turf 4 and they are both currently 1st and 2nd. st marys and dandy west.

-- Edited by sir on Monday 7th of February 2011 08:19:16 PM

__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
prince mark


Status: Offline
Posts: 3187
Date:
Permalink Closed

Every chance nth dandy will be back in turf 2 next year.

HSD have played t3 finals the last few years, there is no way we'd agree to go back to t4, why would we want to put our young players back to a worse standard and stunt their growth

__________________

sir


Status: Offline
Posts: 2136
Date:
Permalink Closed

i understand your point about your 2nds but it would even out over time and be a true reflection on where your club is at. your 2nds have only won two games this year prince,

__________________
what sir wants, sir gets.
«First  <  1 2 3 4 … 8  >  Last»  | Page of 8  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
"The Bloods" Cricket Chat Forum -> DDCA News -> Turf 2 top 4
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard