Turf 2 top 4

sir · Status: Offline

RE: Turf 2 top 4

slocs · Status: Offline

Have a beer after training tonight you's 2 and work it out.

G Train · Status: Offline

just another alias wrote:

Exactly where I was heading train, spot on. The quality of cricket in turf 2 would also improve. I would also rename the top 2 grades.

Yeah you can do that as WGCA did. Wouldn't probably go for Premier, District and Sub-District though, sounds a bit tacky.

sir · Status: Offline

slocs wrote:

Have a beer after training tonight you's 2 and work it out.

whats your thoughts mr ddca? honest.

G Train · Status: Offline

slocs wrote:

Have a beer after training tonight you's 2 and work it out.

Shut up peckerhead. Just because you've got nothing intelligent to add. It's the first decent cricket topic thats been on here in a long time, so we will continue to discuss it, with your blessing or without.

G Train · Status: Offline

sir wrote:

G Train wrote:

Mate, I seriously can't believe you think your idea is better. It's hopeless. I can sort of understand what advantages you see in it. But i really don't think you've looked at the negatives at all, which incidentally far outweigh the positives.

theres negatives and positives no matter what system you introduce. i dont see negatives outweighing positives at all in what ive said.

Ok Sir, explain to me how the promotion relegation system works.

sir · Status: Offline

train, you mentioning WGCA all the time is giving me the shiits. just thought i'd let you know.

G Train · Status: Offline

The WGCA won their first game of country week yesty Sir. They are in a strong position today against Leongatha too.

sir · Status: Offline

bottom team from turf 1 goes down to turf 2 and 1st placed turf 2 goes up to turf 1, the clubs 2nds follow suit no matter where they finish.

sir · Status: Offline

G Train wrote:

The WGCA won their first game of country week yesty Sir. They are in a strong position today against Leongatha too.

good on them, hope they go well.

G Train · Status: Offline

There you go, you've just explained to everyone in one sentence how ridiculous your idea is.

G Train · Status: Offline

sir wrote:

G Train wrote:

The WGCA won their first game of country week yesty Sir. They are in a strong position today against Leongatha too.

good on them, hope they go well.

Following on Twitter. Score updates all day.

just another alias · Status: Offline

slocs is probably preparing his submission as to why turf 1 should be re-named the slocombe shield.

sir · Status: Offline

twitter address?

slocs · Status: Offline

Your call on decent

just another alias · Status: Offline

sir are turf 5 clubs just banished forever under your system?

G Train · Status: Offline

Sounds like it JAA.

sir · Status: Offline

G Train wrote:

There you go, you've just explained to everyone in one sentence how ridiculous your idea is.

why?

G Train · Status: Offline

WGCAwarriors Sir.

G Train · Status: Offline

sir wrote:

G Train wrote:

There you go, you've just explained to everyone in one sentence how ridiculous your idea is.

why?

Ok for example.

Springy Sth finish bottom of Turf 1, but there Turf 3 side wins the flag. This would mean that there 1's drop to Turf 2 (fair enough), but there 2's who just won the flag in Turf 3 drop to Turf 4 (????). Springy Sth 1's then struggle for a few years because the persuader's money has dried up, meanwhile their 2's keep winning outright on the first day because they were the best team in Turf 3 before being relegated. What would then happen if Springy Sth 1's finish bottom of Turf 2? Do there 2's go down to Turf 5? If so, then that defeats the purpose of your Turf 5 proposal and they would start winning outright before tea on day one!

I'll say it again one more time, your proposal is ridiculous and will never work.